Thursday, May 29, 2008

Draft Review #3: the Nomads

In this, the long-awaited third installment of The B.A.R.B. Wire's draft review series, Edgar and Chauncey discuss the selections of the (now) Lexington Rebels, who finished second in the West last year and drafted 7th overall.

Chauncey: Well, that's something you don't see everyday Edgar.
Edgar: What's that, Chauncey?
C: Ronald Melkonian out-thinking himself.
E: Oh, I don't know about that, Chauncey. Everytime Ronald thinks he out-thinks himself.
C: Edgar, Ronald doesn't think that often.
E: You're right. He does most things on impulse. That impulse contributes to his itchy trigger finger.
C: That's the finger that dealt a ton of talent and a top pick for a very good lefthanded starting pitcher and sent one of the best shortstops in the game to Pottsylvania just before the draft.
E: Too bad they didn't acquire the one thing they needed in either of those trades: a pill to stop the impulsive trading you just talked about. Maybe something that causes relaxation.
C: Lexington went into the draft with a very good rotation and lineup, some talented prospects and tons of salary room.
E: They picked up some good arms for the pen and a few good rookies. Good talent, but not much depth. And it can be said they traded Jose Reyes for Joba Chamberlain.
C: Yeah, Chamberlain's good. But James Shields would have been a better pick at this time-- and he still would have had Joba at #4. Ronald continued to shore up the 'pen with Joakim Soria, Jensen Lewis, Yorman Bazardo and Francisco Cordero. Edgar, what other good picks were made?
E: Rich Harden could be a good selection if he makes more than 20 starts for the team. He has the talent, but he can't stay on the mound. Wieters was highly-regarded, and I'm sure at least eight other teams wanted him. Fernando Martinez and Nick Blackburn are both good picks if they pan out.
C: But Martinez has had some attitude issues with the Mets this season. I think the jury is still out on Harden. Let's label that pick "good" or "bad" after the season.
E: So were the needs satisfied?
C: Apparently Trader Ron is still unmedicated, so I'll say NO. And it became apparent after the draft that depth was a major problem-- especially at catcher. What do you think of the trades, Edgar?
E: Again, Reyes for Chamberlain (the #1 pick) was questionable. Or maybe he did it just to have the first selection? That's three or four first overall picks for Ron's team.
C: Yeah, I'm sure you could get a member of his family if you offered him Alex Cintron. You know, the talent of his picks deserves a B+ or an A-, but only getting 9 players and not getting a catcher who can play now drops his grade to B-.
E: Sounds good.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Bullard Baseball history fact #1: At least two of the first four head coaches in Bullard's history graduated from Roosevelt High (Bob Bennett and Tim Thiessen, and it is not known where the first head coach, Bob Steele, went to school). No Bullard grad was head coach of his alma mater until Todd Johnson was hired in 2000.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

You know, on Tuesday, Joba Chamberlain makes his starting debut... as a reliever he posted the following numbers:

23.2 innings:

2.28 ERA
12 HLDS
30 K's
1.14 WHIP

Now he will start and if he thrives as a starter, he would have been by himself more valuable than Jose Reyes; lets not forget, I also got:

- OF Colby Rasmus
- C Matt Wieters (with a pick from that trade)
- and someone else but I forgot lol

POINT: Jose Reyes for Chamberlain, Wieters, and Rasmus alone is worth more than Reyes, who was replaced with J.J. Hardy.

Also, Reyes isn't having the same kind of season he has had the past two years, and will not achieve the same stolen base amount like last year due to his team's change in policy.

NOW, I think it is pretty clear that that trade I have done has turned out to be a good one.

Anonymous said...

Also, Chamberlain will not only this year but the next, be unestablished and will qualify as not only a stone in the pen, put as a starter now.

ALSO, Reyes is battling hammy problems, soemthing that took him out of the game a couple of years ago. May be an injury risk now???